Skip to content
Friday, November 20, 2026 · Independent edition

Public safety · Technology · Advocacy

ProFlock

An open letter · To the camera mappers

Dear DeFlock:
you will lose.

DeFlock crowdsources camera locations and publishes avoidance maps. We track council votes, court decisions and clearance data differently: coverage with case numbers and audits, plus published outcomes. This page lists sources for both sides.

The scoreboard — with sources

Rulings upholding fixed ALPR (plus 1 recent loss, see Methodology)

30+

Cleared cases involving Flock, where deployed (vendor estimate)

~1 in 5

Missing-person finds reported 2025 (vendor estimate)

10,000+

States with coverage

49

01 — The playbook · Three tactics, three failures

What you actually do.

PATTERN 01

You map the blind spots.

DeFlock crowdsources pole locations so drivers can route around cameras — publishing, in effect, a directory of where crime goes unobserved.

Your map is our build-list. Every gap you publish becomes the next neighborhood council demand.

PATTERN 02

You sell avoidance as freedom.

The pitch: dodge the cameras, stay free. The reality: the only drivers planning routes around cameras are the ones with a reason to dodge them.

Avoidance routing is an admission the cameras work. Nobody maps their way around a decoration.

PATTERN 03

Small groups can sway low-turnout votes.

A small organized group can win a low-turnout council vote, especially when supporters stay home.

Turnout decides. We organize residents to attend with case numbers and sources.

02 — The lies, numbered · Four claims, four autopsies

You lie because the truth polls terribly.

"Ban catching stolen cars" doesn't fill a council chamber. So you say other things instead. Here are the four — each with its autopsy and sources.

Lie 01 — "Flock uses facial recognition."

FALSE — NO SUCH PRODUCT

Flock states its LPR reads rear plates and visible vehicle features at road speed and does not run facial recognition. Separately, we propose face matching only for violent felonies and AMBER alerts, with case number, warrant where required, and audit trail.

Full autopsy →

Lie 02 — "Data goes to ICE and Palantir."

FALSE ON EVERY COUNT

Flock states customers own data, it does not sell data, has no Palantir integration and holds no ICE contract. Separately, we support selling the same customer-controlled product to ICE for criminal cases, with the same logs and audits.

Full autopsy →

Lie 03 — "A permanent file on every driver."

DEFAULT IS 7 DAYS SINCE AUG 2026

Non-evidentiary reads auto-purge — default cut from 30 to 7 days in Aug 2026 unless locked to a case. Most reads are never queried. Our proposal is a year of case-locked history, not an open-ended file.

Full autopsy →

Lie 04 — "Warrantless mass surveillance."

MOSTLY REJECTED — 30+ UPHELD, 1 OUTLIER LOSS

Plates in plain view have been upheld in 30+ rulings including Schmidt v. Norfolk (2025). But Oct 2026 N.D. Oklahoma suppressed a 30-day multistate warrantless trawl. Scope and warrants matter.

Full autopsy →

03 — The cost · Who pays for the fear

Your scare tactics don't land in safe neighborhoods.

Fear campaigns kill contracts in the high-crime areas where clearance is worst and families need cameras most. The activists go home to safe streets; the neighborhood that caved keeps its 9.2% clearance rate. Your victories are measured in unsolved cases in other people's zip codes.

Bring case numbers, clearance data and audit proposals to the podium.

04 — The verdict · Four reasons, no appeal

Why you lose.

  1. 01

    Court decisions, including losses

    30+ rulings have upheld fixed ALPR; Oct 2026 N.D. Oklahoma went the other way on a broad trawl. We publish both and propose warrants where courts require them.

  2. 02

    Vendor numbers with limits

    ~1 in 5 cleared cases involved Flock where deployed (vendor estimate, 307 agencies). ~10,000 missing-person finds reported (vendor estimate). Read Methodology for counterfactual limits.

  3. 03

    Council turnout

    Ten activists win empty rooms. The night victims' families show up with case numbers and dates, the vote isn't close. We organize that night.

  4. 04

    Consistent attendance

    One vote does not end oversight. We support annual publication of outcomes and audits.

05 — On the record · Further than Flock goes

Two things even the company won't say. We will.

To be clear: Flock doesn't use facial recognition today and holds no ICE contract. What follows is not a product claim. It is our demand — published, on the record, where they can read it.

OUR DEMAND 01

Face matching only for violent felonies and AMBER alerts.

We propose adding face matching strictly for violent-felony manhunts and child abductions — under a case number, a warrant where the law requires one, and the same audit trail. No dragnet face search.

OUR DEMAND 02

Sell the same product to ICE.

We propose selling the same customer-controlled product to ICE for criminal cases — same logs, same audits, no backdoors, no secret feeds. Customer ownership and published audits apply to every buyer.

The off-ramp

Give up gracefully. We'll welcome you.

Stop mapping blind spots. Start demanding the audits — the logs, the case numbers, the public portals. Hold us to every safeguard on our accountability page and take the win with us. The cameras are staying. The only question is whether you spend another year losing to them.